Who, Where and When photos



  Are you seeing "Red" Yet?  This is ...

Read more

When we published this photo of 14 police ...

Read more

A 'Motley Crew' from Cycle Squad We told you ...

Read more

There was no prize for guessing that this is a ...

Read more

  While writing a recent article on our ...

Read more

  How about this for an exceptionally smart ...

Read more

  We mentioned that this photo has a strong ...

Read more

  We received the following two photographs ...

Read more

We recently came into possession of this photo ...

Read more

  Shortly before this year's Cup Match this ...

Read more

A Grand Reunion in Edinburgh We described this ...

Read more

  No prizes for guessing where this photo ...

Read more

This had to be the largest number of people we ...

Read more

A Merry Christmas Indeed   It was with a ...

Read more

A Smart Group! We said it shouldn't be too ...

Read more

Our latest photo was taken at a social gathering ...

Read more

A SPECIAL (BRANCH) PHOTO We came into possession ...

Read more

  Official Opening of the "new" St. ...

Read more

This is our second recent wedding photo being ...

Read more

We had recently received this photo and wanted to ...

Read more

We first published this photo in our Who, Where ...

Read more

An Eastern Flavour! This is the second large ...

Read more

An Unforgettable Day This is without doubt the ...

Read more

No prizes for telling us that this is a poster ...

Read more

  Anyone who served in the Bermuda Police ...

Read more

We posted this photo after adding it to the ...

Read more

Who is this "Best Dressed" crew? Here's a "Who, ...

Read more

This photo is taken directly from the new book on ...

Read more

Boating and Beer! No, this was not a photograph ...

Read more

Boxing Contestants and officials As mentioned ...

Read more

  The Boys in Blue  - in black ties! It's not ...

Read more

Camouflage Crew! We just received this photo as ...

Read more

Cann Anyone Identify the Celebrities and the ...

Read more

Central CID Party for Angus Brown's 40th ...

Read more

  How's this for a photo of photographers! ...

Read more

Frank "Gruff" Hammond's Retirement Photo Not ...

Read more

We normally feature photos from the more distant ...

Read more

Disco Dungeon! We were  certain that anyone ...

Read more

Eastern Division Football Stars    We ...

Read more

We have just received this copy of a front page ...

Read more

  At first glance this appears to be a ...

Read more

Farewell to Tony Nuttall We clearly had a very ...

Read more

Fearless Fighters We  received a series of ...

Read more

Fifty six men in uniform This is the largest ...

Read more

First Bermuda Police Hockey Team We had an ...

Read more

First Police Mini-Marathon 1968 This photo, ...

Read more

We had recently come into possession of these ...

Read more

  No prize for guessing what sport these ...

Read more

Football Team with a Cup Our latest photo, ...

Read more

We pointed out that all of the persons in the ...

Read more

Fresh off the Plane - September ...

Read more

  We recently received this photo of a ...

Read more

   As stated when we first published ...

Read more

We had just recently received these photos of a ...

Read more

Good Darts! These gentlemen may not have been ...

Read more

We said there is more than one legendary ...

Read more

WHAT A CRICKET TEAM! We believe this photo shows ...

Read more

Great Sounds I thought it appropriate at this ...

Read more

Happy 10th Anniversary in Bermuda - March ...

Read more

Harmonious Group We were sure you would know ...

Read more

This photograph made history for what it was used ...

Read more

We had recently received this photograph from ...

Read more

This excellent photo is taken from page 36 of our ...

Read more

We recently received a copy of this photo and ...

Read more

Update -  19th February 2016 We have just ...

Read more

Riot Squad in training Apologies first for the ...

Read more

Riot Squad in training Apologies first for the ...

Read more

Karate Anyone? We didn't offer a prize for ...

Read more

Kilting Around We recently received these three ...

Read more

We recently received this group photo from former ...

Read more

Yes, we knew these officers were all in Western ...

Read more

  We have just been kindly provided with ...

Read more

Murder Squad Team - September 1971   Here ...

Read more

New Recruits We had just received this ...

Read more

Stepping Back in Time We have just come into ...

Read more

Here is another photo we recently received which ...

Read more

Although most of our members may never have ...

Read more

There were no prizes for guessing that this was a ...

Read more

This group of footballers were off on a tour, and ...

Read more

    We just received this photo of a ...

Read more

One man and his dog host a CID ...

Read more

Pin-up of the Season! This is probably the one ...

Read more

We recently came into possession of these three ...

Read more

We recently come into possession of this ...

Read more

Police Boxing Trip to Massachusetts  - ...

Read more

  We had recently come into possession of ...

Read more

  How about this group to challenge your ...

Read more

The Irish Connection We published this photo on ...

Read more

Police Thespians on Stage  We asked what ...

Read more

Who remembers khaki uniforms? This photo is ...

Read more

  This photograph is also featured in our ...

Read more

This is NOT an advert for Smirnoff Vodka Our ...

Read more

Salty Group It wasn't too difficult to figure ...

Read more

This photo surely gave us a nostalgic glimpse of ...

Read more

  We received this photo in response to the ...

Read more

Ship Ahoy! There were no prizes for guessing ...

Read more

 There were no prizes for guessing which ...

Read more

  We recently poached this photo of a group ...

Read more

We asked if you could remember the days when we ...

Read more

  When posting this photograph we said ...

Read more

 Some Team! Joint Importation Squad This was ...

Read more

St. George's Police Barracks - 1964 This photo ...

Read more

Ten Uniformed Police Officers This photo was ...

Read more

The Best in the West We recently came into ...

Read more

  THREE "MOD" SQUAD DETCTIVES   We ...

Read more

Here's a change from our usual "Who, Where and ...

Read more

When we first published this photo we pointed out ...

Read more

Training School in the Mid-sixties This photo ...

Read more

There were no prizes for figuring out that this ...

Read more

It wouldn't take long to realize that one of the ...

Read more

  Halloween Party at Faraway Cottages - ...

Read more

  This was not the best quality photo we ...

Read more

  What was a group of policemen doing in ...

Read more

What do these men all have in common? Our photo ...

Read more

We knew exactly where and when and why this ...

Read more

  We recently came into possession of these ...

Read more

We thought this would be a most appropriate photo ...

Read more

Which Division is this?   Western As we ...

Read more

  We received this photograph of a team of ...

Read more

  This is the first time we have featured a ...

Read more

This section of our website is designed for two ...

Read more

Who's arriving on this BOAC Flight? We posted ...

Read more

We recently came into possession of this wedding ...

Read more

Why this Gathering? We said the poeple in this ...

Read more

Prev Next
2nd February 1965 will forever be remembered by anyone serving in the Bermuda Police Force at that time as the day of the BELCO Riot. There have been several accounts of what took place that day, none of which were told from the point of view of those police officers who were present.

On the 48th anniversary of the BELCO Riot, the Royal Gazette  kindly published just such an account from one of the young officers who was there. (CLICK HERE to view article in the Royal Gazette).David Mulhall served in the Bermuda Police for only a year before moving to Canada where he went on to become a university history professor. Dave was not only there that morning but he was also injured by the rioters, and it is possible the head injuries he sustained that morning could have contributed to the Parkinson’s he now sadly suffers from.

P.C. David Mulhall (centre) with P.C. Peter O'Shea (left) and the late P.C. Wilie Galloway (right),  
outside Police Headquarters at Prospect circa 1964

Dave is in the process of writing his memoirs for our “Then and Now” column and we look forward to publishing them as soon as they are completed – hopefully within a couple of months. In the meantime he has extracted his account of the BELCO Riot and provided it to the Royal Gazette.  The article is also published below.

This account varies somewhat from those given by persons who wrote from the rioters point of views, but we will leave you to judge whether or not Dave’s version of events is the most accurate. Ironically, Dave makes it clear that he had great sympathy with the BIU’s efforts to unionize the Bermuda Electric Light Company.

Here is the article in full:-

BERMUDA: THE 1965 BELCO RIOT

A PERSONAL MEMOIR

David Mulhall

When I left England in 1964 to train to be a police officer in Bermuda, I did not expect that within a few months I would be beaten by rioters with whose cause I openly sympathized.

And I certainly could not have imagined that this experience would influence my decision to abandon my “playing the field” approach to dating in favor of “going steady” with a young Canadian nurse I had met on a “blind date.” Her name was Frances Warner, and soon she could be regularly spotted riding side-saddle on my BSA motor-bike.

It was not until I had, by chance, observed her in action on duty that I wanted her to be the only “date” to ride pillion on my BSA. But since she worked on the Children’s Ward at King Edward Hospital, and I normally did not venture beyond the Emergency entrance, I might never have seen her at work.

February 2,1965 was not a normal day, however, for on that day I did have the opportunity to observe her in action. In the late morning she was sent down to help the Emergency staff cope with 17 policemen injured in a clash with a large, angry mob of striking workers at the Bermuda Electric Light Company (BELCO) plant on Serpentine Road.

I happened to be one of those injured policemen and I lay on a table with my head facing the door having a cut on my chin sutured when she walked in, spotted me and without a word or gesture promptly went to tend to Constable Ian Davies, who had a severe head injury from which he would never recover. Ian had been assigned to the Police Garage fixing police cars because he did not seem to be cut out for the rough and tumble of police work. He had befriended me when I arrived in Bermuda. I remember him driving me to Admiralty House in his spotless MG sports car and spending the afternoon teaching me how to sail.

At the time I thought I had been lucky to have sustained just multiple cuts and bruises. I now know that the Parkinson's disease, which ended my academic career prematurely, may be linked to the blows to my face and head.

Given Bermudians' strong, almost morbid preoccupation with race and the close correlation of race with social and class status, labor/management conflicts invariably became racial in nature. Interestingly, according to police intelligence reports, the "racialization" of the BELCO strike seems to have occurred despite the union leaders' efforts to "contain" it .The BIU's members were overwhelmingly hourly-paid blacks; BELCO's owners and most of the salaried staff were white.

Any negotiations between the two parties would inevitably be soured, on the BIU side of the table, by the persistence of such blatantly racist practices as the segregation of facilities like washrooms. Across the table, BIU's energetic and successful leadership of Bermuda's trade union and Civil Rights' movements was bound to upset and frighten the white colonial elite which essentially “owned” not only the big companies like BELCO but, despite being a minority, the government itself. The prospect of one day having to defend the interests of this powerful oligarchy made me feel uncomfortable. I admired Dr. Martin Luther King and openly sympathized with the BIU’s commitment to Bermuda’s political and social democratization.

One of the most important of those elite interests was the Bermuda Electric Light Company. By late 1964, a substantial number of its hourly-paid employees, mostly linemen, had joined the BIU, which then approached the company to request recognition and bargaining rights. BELCO agreed to negotiate, and after a number of meetings with the BIU's leaders, offered to recognize the union if at least 51% of BELCO's hourly-paid workers voted in favor of joining it.

Fearing that it would not win at the ballot box, and seriously over-estimating its ability to disrupt the company's operations, on January 14, 1965, the Union called its members out on strike. Despite the use of aggressive and clearly illegal picketing, as well as some dynamiting of company installations, the Company remained adamant in its refusal to accept the BIU's original demands.

The Union was used to winning unionization campaigns, and its leaders reacted to the humiliating prospect of failure by an escalation of tactics and the appearance of a greatly intensified rhetoric of abuse and violent threats. The police bore the brunt of this frequently openly racist vitriol.

On February 1, police intelligence officers predicted that violence would break out the following morning. For not only had the mood of the BELCO strikers become more openly belligerent, but that evening the BIU called on all its members in other industries to join it in a general, sympathy strike, and to demonstrate their solidarity by joining the BELCO picket line the next morning.

By mid-morning, the picketers outnumbered the police by an estimated 6 or 7 to 1. This overwhelming response sealed the fate of the absurdly small, unarmed, untrained, young and inexperienced group of constables, most of whom, like me, spent their days posing for tourists who had to have at least one snap of a real “Bobby.” I regarded the helmets we wore as little better than theatrical props, for they provided little protection against either the sun or assailants.

Some 45 years later BIU president Simmons told a young and deferential journalist that it was at this point that "metal pipe wielding" police "attacked" the striking pickets, who had of course to defend themselves. The metal pipes are a figment of Mr. Simmons' imagination.

The police "attack" occurred after a group of non-unionized workers asked the police to open the picket line so that they could exercise their legal right to go to work. When three policemen approached the picket line, they were set upon and severely beaten by a group of about 60 men, many of them armed with weapons from a central cache.

This deliberate, obviously planned and potentially lethal resort to armed aggression against the unarmed and vastly outnumbered police is probably best understood as a result of turning the solid, unbroken picket line into a symbol of union and, perhaps, racial solidarity. It would follow that any attempt to "break" it would be felt as a humiliating provocation that warranted a violent, punitive reaction.

As more weapons were passed along the picket lines, so assaults on police officers, usually those traveling in small groups, became more frequent. Still the riot control units held on reserve at Prospect and the Hamilton Police Station were not called in. Instead, seven unarmed and unprotected men were sent in a police van to seize the weapons and to arrest those who were distributing them.

Predictably, these men were attacked and badly beaten. From about a hundred yards away I saw Ian Davies, one of the seven, being beaten by several men as he lay unconscious and bleeding profusely from a head wound. I ran to help, though I do not know how. Then, as I approached one of the assailants from behind, he raised a golf club above his head. Acting before thinking, I wrenched the putting iron from his hands before he could bring it down on Ian’s head again.

I then experienced an intense wave of irrational self-satisfaction and relief as I threw it over a nearby wall. Perhaps foolishly, it never occurred to me to use it, or the toy-like police issue baton to defend myself against the four or five assailants I had not disarmed. Quite possibly, the enraged rioters would have turned on me with more murderous intent had I used my captured golf iron on them.

Angered at having their beating of an unconscious man interrupted, they left Ian and turned on me with their motley array of improvised weapons: iron reinforcing rods, lengths of 2 by 4 wood, baseball bats, and my tiny baton, which one of them yanked out of its concealed pocket while I was in my defensive tortoise mode.

Because I had taken some advanced first aid/medic courses in the U.K., I attended to Ian while Constable George Linnen put himself between Ian and the rioters who were hurling rocks and bottles from across the street.

I think I very briefly lost consciousness when I hit the roadway "chin first." At that point, surrendering to instinct, I curled up in a ball and wrapped my arms and hands around my head.

Fortunately, the long-delayed arrival of police reinforcements scared off my attackers. A quick look at Ian's injuries convinced me that his skull was fractured and that he was losing a good deal of blood from scalp lacerations Putting into practice what I had learned from a simulated "scenario" involving very similar injuries, I shouted for officers to give me their standard winter uniform ties, which I made into a donut-shaped compress designed to apply light pressure to his hemorrhaging scalp. There was nothing more I could or should have done to treat his fractured skull.

An ambulance sent for the police casualties was blocked for some time by the mob. Shortly afterwards, but too late help the injured seventeen, the riot units quickly, and with minimal discomfort for the rioters, cleared the street. The BELCO Riot was over.

A BRIEF CRITICAL ANALYSIS

The only extant written description of the police role in this "Disturbance" is a report prepared at the behest of Commissioner George Robins by Inspector J. C. P. Hanlon, a sort of in-house P.R. man. A copy of the report was sent the Colonial Secretary in London. Clearly intended to divert attention away from the apportioning of blame, it does so by ignoring the whole question of personal responsibility and avoiding any critical analysis. Things just happened.

The reader is told, for example, that small groups of policemen, unarmed, untrained, and unprotected by proper riot clothing and gear, were ordered to disarm an enraged mob of about 300, but there is no mention of who gave that absurd order - and why. Similarly, the failure to provide any kind of crowd or riot control training at the Training School is simply not raised. Nor is the decision to deploy the two riot control units only after 17 men were injured.

No wonder Commissioner Robins thanked Hanlon "very much for this excellent report...." For the first two weeks of the strike Commissioner Robins' pursued a policy of appeasement - what might be called "reckless restraint." Designed, presumably, to avoid confrontations which might get out of hand, and thereby tarnish Bermuda's image, it had the opposite effect, as, for example, when illegal picketing became more aggressive once it became obvious that the law would not be enforced. Hanlon does concede that "to a certain extent" the decision to ignore this flouting of the law did contribute to further lawlessness.

By mid-morning on February 2, aware that his men had lost control, Robins apparently abandoned appeasement in favor of vigorous and prompt restoration of the rule of law. This meant breaking the picket line and disarming the rioters using the manpower and little truncheons originally mustered to implement the appeasement policy. Why Robins did not order a tactical disengagement until the riot control units arrived remains a mystery.

David Mulhall

Kelowna, B.C.

January 2013

Editors Note-

For the record, eight of the police officers who were present that morning were later recognized for their bravery with the following awards:-

Colonial Police Medal for Gallantry
Inspector Robert Ball
PC Ian Davies
PC Michael Caulkett
PC Andrew Bermingham
Colonial Police Medal for Meritorious Service
Sergeant John Cafferkey
Sergeant Ken Morris
PC Gilmour Simons
WPC Christine Muspratt
We invite your comments below
February 6th 2013
We just received some comments from former PC Ray Sousa about his recollections of the impact of the BELCO Riot  (he joined the Bermuda Police shortly afterwards) and the 1968 Riot on his life.  Ray's comments can be seen in our 'Keeping in Touch' column dated 6th February.  CLICK HERE to view 'Keeping in Touch'.
Tagged Under

Comments  

#4 Davie Kerr 2014-03-13 18:21
What's the deal with comment #3?

Editors note - That's a great question Devie and thanks for spotting it. I constantly have totally crazy comments sent by people who write complete rubbish for whatever reason, and have nothing whatever to do with our Association. I receive and send to the trash dozens every week before approving comments, but this one slipped through. Please let me know if you see any others.
Quote
#3 http:// 2014-03-07 13:14
In fact when someone doesn't be aware of then its up to other users that
they will help, so here it happens.
Quote
#2 Terry Cabral 2013-03-22 14:53
I was there also along with Arthur Childs as he tended the numerous weapons he had inside his shop at the eastern entrance to BELCO.
He was making lunch and I was sharpening lawnmower blades.
History is a beach.
Quote
#1 Davie Kerr 2013-02-08 04:31
The PC identified as the late Willie GALLAGHER is in fact the late Willie GALLOWAY, with whose best mate I served in Dundee before joining Bermuda. Oddly enough, Willie joined the Bermuda Police because at the time he was too short for any Scottish force!

Apologies for the typo. Correction made.
Editor
Quote

Add comment


Security code
Refresh